Today,
We're joined by my friend,
Meditation teacher and author,
Jeff Warren.
First,
Let's slow down and come into a brief embodied practice together.
Just slowly bringing your attention.
Somewhere down into the center of your body.
And just noticing where you are inside,
How safe you feel in your body.
A nice little invitation to slow things down a little bit.
Oh,
Yeah.
The wisdom of the pause.
So we're going to be really exploring today this kind of rich conversation about working with the felt sense inside the body and with meditation.
Just notice what happens inside when we're with all of that.
Being in this beautiful community where we really advocate for the body.
To really befriend our body.
And then just slowly.
Coming back.
Bringing yourself back into the room and to being together and,
Hey,
Well,
And what's exciting for you right now,
I know you've got lots of great projects going on as you always do.
Um,
But for those of,
You know,
People that don't know much about who you are.
Share with us what's going on for Jeff Warren these days.
Uh,
Well,
Um.
.
.
I mean,
A lot.
Primarily,
I'm a dad of two young kids,
So my- Well,
That'll be a lot.
Yeah,
We have a three-year-old and a six-year-old,
So that's kind of our.
.
.
I was literally doing a version of Felt Sense this morning as my two boys were screaming at each other.
I was like,
Okay,
I do my usual practice around that.
Because for me,
It's like I'm being electrocuted on the inside.
My wife,
Her default,
In terms of her less healthy strategies,
More of a kind of like freeze a little bit or more like have space to the when it gets dysfunctional is a little dissociative.
Mine is more like it's all up in my system when they're because I'm so sensitive.
So I have specific strategies I use around that.
So that's a big part of my life.
But I'm a teacher of meditation and mindfulness.
I specialize in making practices accessible to very different kinds of populations and neurodivergent.
So I talk a lot about my ADHD and my bipolar,
I've had to figure out how to change,
How to adjust my own mindfulness practice and beyond that,
Just the kind of core skills of practice more broadly and to figure out how they work for me.
And I've learned a lot about that.
So I spend a lot of kind of very joyful time,
Um,
Doing that.
And I'm pretty broadly informed about like,
You know,
Trauma stuff,
Cause it's just so interesting to me.
I feel like it's sort of articulating from a biological point of view,
I guess,
A lot of what say traditional Buddhism or Indian philosophy has talked about in different terms,
But I see a lot of overlap.
And I guess my big passion is what I would call the democratization of mental health.
So helping everyone get connected to a practice and a support system.
And it often involves community that kind of works for them and speaks to where they're at.
And I hear part of the reason I'm so excited about this is I know Jan very well,
And she knows me very well because she is my former therapist.
So back in the day,
Back in the dark old days,
I think this was like 2008 or something,
I think.
It's a long time ago.
It was a long time,
Almost 20 years.
Yeah.
I was going through a very hard time.
I had just published my- And you,
Jeff,
You used to come and sit here in this room.
I recognized the space.
Yeah.
I would come in and,
You know,
Like the people would pass each other by in the hallways.
We were shamefully,
We were in therapy.
We didn't want other people to know we were in therapy.
There was something kind of the taboo is still very much alive.
Then we would pass each other in the hallway,
You know,
And someone would go out and I would come in.
And at that time in my life,
I had written my first big book about consciousness that came out and I was sort of free falling.
I had a,
I'd really had thrown myself into meditation practice and it was a support,
But it also was creating interesting areas of dysregulation,
Which we can,
I'm no doubt we'll get into.
And I got,
I was broke and lost and struggling and somehow I got got connected to Jan Winhall,
Someone.
How was that?
I think it was Patricia Pearson,
Actually.
Oh,
Yeah,
It was.
It was.
Patricia Pearson,
Who's a great writer.
That's right.
She was like,
You should connect to Jan.
I was like,
I'd love to,
But I'm dead broke and I'm in free fall.
And you were like,
You know what?
After you met me,
You said,
I'll,
You know,
I'll see you for free,
Basically.
And for like two or three years.
I did?
Yo,
Yeah,
You saw me.
I didn't pay.
I think I paid $20 a session,
Which was because I had,
I didn't have a penny to my name.
I was in major tailspins around mental health stuff.
And,
And then you also then convinced me to do the,
Uh,
Felt sense,
Uh,
The training.
So I did,
I did at least two years of training with you,
With our group where we learned felt sense.
And I,
I got very deep into the,
Into Jenlin's work and became,
It became the whole episode.
Not only did it.
Correct course,
Correct me from a mental health perspective and all kinds of ways we can talk about,
But that the felt sense model became very central to how I started to,
When I eventually a few years later started to teach meditation,
It was very much at the center of how I thought about practice and still is very much at the center.
Although there's differences.
Yes.
So there's so much there that we can impact.
And since we have such a,
We have a personal connection,
It's extra interesting.
And I'm also happy to talk about all of my neurotic Neurodivergent trauma.
But you know what else we went through,
Which was really powerful,
Right?
Was the death of someone that was very dear to us,
Right?
Arlene.
Yeah.
Yeah,
She was also,
Thank you for saying she was a central part of this.
You introduced me to Marlene.
She became my ADHD coach and helped me put structures in place that to this day are very much how I structure my life and also saw me completely for free.
So I had the two of you.
And then when she died,
It was,
Terrible.
Yeah,
That was.
.
.
Yeah,
It's a it's funny talking about it now going back to that.
I remember seeing you at her funeral at her service and I've been one of the last times I saw you actually in person.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Boy,
Oh boy.
I remember the emails that you sent me after that and Yeah,
It's a powerful thing,
Isn't it,
When you share a grief?
Yeah.
It's a really powerful,
It bonds you.
Yeah.
So you said something just before we came on air,
Actually,
About how you had a meditation practice,
But what you were experiencing at the time that you came to see me There was something about needing something more or different to help you with what you were.
So I think it would be really great for our audience if you could share something about,
Because often people think focusing is meditation.
And focusing isn't meditation.
No,
There's a lot of overlap.
You know,
There is overlap,
Especially step one,
Right?
In clearing a space.
But focusing,
Jenlin found focusing through working with people who had problems and wanted to basically be with those problems in a way that it could be resourceful and helpful.
Yes.
Well,
This is a very rich thing to discuss,
And maybe I'll just set it up by just offering a framework for how I think about it.
Yeah,
Please do.
For how I think about the nature of the healing that happens in meditation,
And maybe the nature of the healing that happens through focusing.
Great,
I love this.
And you can add to that,
Obviously,
Because it'll be limited.
First of all,
Of course,
There are many kinds of meditation techniques that have different intentions that do different things or different kinds of trainings.
But if you're talking about mindfulness in particular,
And I'm very influenced by my main teacher here is a guy named Shinzen Young,
And he really spoke about mindfulness as this sort of cultivation of a three-part attentional skill set.
So you're building up,
In his view,
And I agree,
You're building up concentration,
Which is the capacity to choose what you want to pay attention to,
To direct your attention and begin to kind of commit.
You're cultivating clarity.
Which is more,
Uh,
Kind of resolution in the inner world,
More,
Very much like focusing does like getting clear about what's happening in experience.
Um,
And finally you're,
You're cultivating equanimity,
Which is the,
Um,
The kind of super juice to all of that.
We also cultivating care and compassion,
These things,
But the equanimity is really the non attachment.
It's the not pushing and pulling the being with something without needing to push it away or check out from it.
And it is the very quality of building a,
A window of tolerance that we talk about in trauma therapy,
Like more capacity to be with more kinds of intensities with having ever more space.
So the direction of healing in a meditation practice in a very general sense is the,
Um,
Whatever's coming up in the,
As the,
As the,
In the figure who say to figure ground relationship,
Whatever intensity of conditions internally conditions externally are happening,
You are learning to via equanimity to cultivate ever more sense of presence.
So that you're less and less dysregulated to that and more able to stay there with it.
And mostly it happens sort of through a trickle down process.
Every day you come and you sit in your practice,
You develop more,
A little bit more equanimity,
A little bit more concentration.
It trickles down.
It begins to open things up to shift things.
And there can be a sense in which things are clearing out.
You feel like it's almost like to use your language,
The body begins to reorganize itself in more adaptive ways.
And I really think that's true.
Come out of a session and realize you're just generally less reactive around this person.
And there can be dramatic shifts,
Not only dramatic falling aways of traumatic patterns where they just get integrated in a way without even you having to specifically work directly on them.
Of course,
There are the more profound shifts associated with the practice where even your sense of a self in here and a world out there,
It turns out that's something else that can be seen with concentration,
Clarity,
And equanimity.
And as that starts to erode,
Your capacity to feel connected to life,
To act on your own kind of deepest intuitions,
All of that grows your own creativity.
So,
I mean,
That's a very general broad sense.
It happens in different ways for different people.
But I would say that's a kind of overview of say the,
And then what is the intention of say a Buddhist practice is to diminish suffering and increase fulfillment really.
And it sends you into a kind of path of healing that is ultimately still quite mysterious.
Like you could,
There are stages that are recognizable,
But it's so unique and quirky and dependent on the person.
Now,
What happens when we sit and get present with our stuff?
Well,
It comes to meet us.
Here it is.
Here,
Hello.
We're not a blank slate.
We got all this history.
We got all this stuff.
And sometimes in the slow march of perspective that increases through practice,
We find we have the capacity to be with that stuff.
Other times it's too intense.
And it may be that the direct skills of meditation that you're trying to apply at that moment,
They're just not enough.
You do not have capacity.
And that's what happened with me.
Like I experienced a ton of deep healing at the beginning.
First few years of my practice were more of a sense of presence being available more.
Like I never knew how much noise there was in my system until it started to get quiet.
And that is profound.
And then as if I had exfoliated the top layers,
Here comes the boogeyman.
Here comes all the gnarly stuff,
This shame,
The agony,
The pain,
The dysregulation.
And it was I did not have enough capacity to be with that on my own And my teacher at the time his advice the classic meditation advice is a version of this just recycle the reaction Whatever intensity is coming through just bring equanimity.
Pardon me Concentration and clarity to it and eventually you can use that as the new meditation object and you'll Develop that much more capacity easy to say if you're not bipolar my friend easy to say if you're not ADHD easy to say if you don't have a lot of trauma,
Much harder to do in practice.
So what I found is I needed,
Like,
I think of the trickle-down approach of meditation in contrast to a more directed and targeted,
Like,
Let's actually work with this pattern.
Let's look at it.
You can do that in meditation.
Pardon me.
You can use like Tara Brock's reign,
You can work with specific things,
But to do it with someone,
Another human being who's attuning to you,
Who you're attuned to,
That collectively expands the bandwidth of our capacity to socially meet this thing,
The safety you feel,
Of course,
Because you're also healing your relations to other people.
So you have this,
You know,
In my case,
I had you who could sit with me as this compassionate person who could direct me into working working specifically with the pattern as it's coming up,
Like I needed that.
And I think that even for meditators who may not specifically need that,
Pardon me,
I got this chest thing.
It's okay,
Take your time.
Because I'm getting excited talking about it.
Even for meditators who may not specifically need that,
You can go deep in a meditation practice.
You can address all kinds of core suffering,
But if you don't acknowledge your shadow,
Your stuff,
It may not cause you suffering in the way it used to,
But you can bet it'll displace your suffering onto other people.
And then you have the classic acting out in a spiritual,
The kind of,
You know,
Different words for the bypassing.
Yeah,
You bypass your own stuff and it ends up being,
Comes back to bite you later on.
And those folks,
Jeff,
When people are at that place and they come into my focusing trainings,
They have a really tough time because they expect as meditators,
Focusing is going to be like a piece of cake.
And then they're the ones that really get challenged and scared.
Absolutely,
Because it's like,
First of all,
It challenges their ideal of the perfect meditator and whatever spiritual attainment they've achieved,
Which is all kind of ridiculous,
You know,
Cul-de-sacs on the path.
And then,
Like you said,
They may never have gone into those specific things,
And those activations are huge.
They're huge,
Yeah.
My working definition of trauma as a meditator,
Like I'm saying,
From the point of view of like the phenomenology,
Like the experience of trauma,
Of trauma is that which seems to come out of nowhere.
Like I'm fine.
I'm regulated.
I'm in this like I have a sense of my an easy presence in the world.
And then my son is screaming at me or freaking out.
And all of a sudden it's like flashbacks of my own stuff I dealt with as a kid.
It's like I'm like I can I'm no longer in touch with my body.
I'm I'm immersed in his drama.
I have flashback.
I have like literally intrusive thoughts of doing violence to my son of things that have been done me like I'm hijacked by this limbic thing and it's like I'm in I'm trapped inside this new world and that to me is like trauma when it comes out of nowhere and you're and you're inside the experience of it and then what do you do?
You used to call that fresh frozen.
Yeah,
These triggers,
Because they're frozen in time,
But they're fresh when they're touched.
Yes,
And it feels like being re-traumatized.
Yeah,
Well,
It is.
It is.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And that's despite whatever meditation or focusing practice you may have had,
This stuff is still.
.
.
So for me,
I got to a point in my own journey where I was like,
Okay,
There are some major things here.
And then the neurodivergent aspect is a whole other level.
And of course,
Neurodivergent folks often have a lot more trauma.
So I had both those things.
So there's stuff I need to address different way.
And then I did do and I continue to have done,
Although I'd say that I'm at a very different place with it now,
20 years later,
Not just through the work I've done with you,
But other trauma therapists.
And I have a completely different relationship to my trauma now that I used to have.
And it's part of what I teach.
So maybe we can break that down a little bit more.
How you use in your own experiencing the shifting from the meditation practice into the focusing practice of coming into and being with these fresh frozen trauma places?
Yeah,
Sure.
Well,
First of all,
I don't even use categories anymore,
Honestly,
Of this is mindfulness,
This is compassion,
This is self-sense.
But I think it's helped,
But it's,
I know what you mean,
But I think for people when,
Especially when we're trying to teach it.
Totally,
No,
I'm happy to do it that way,
But I'm just saying it's like,
I just have my practice and the right practice is the one that works for me and this is what it looks like.
Uh,
I'll be,
I can give you a different,
I mean,
I have so many,
But I could give you the one I do when I'm in the middle of the shit storm.
And then I can give you the one I do as a more general one because they are both involved.
Focusing the,
The general one looks like when I can do my daily practice,
I sit down,
I,
You know,
I close my eyes to start.
I often,
For me,
It's like from the beginning,
I,
I make it about something larger than me.
So I connect to,
You know,
I asked for support.
I feel the sense of.
Lineage connection of my mentors.
Like I really am deliberate about like I'm about connecting out that way.
And it puts me in a position of sort of,
It's an instant equanimity inducer.
It makes me more humble,
More kind of available.
And then I usually,
I usually do something where I'm like,
I do a very focusing question.
I say to myself,
What's here now that I didn't realize was here.
What's here now that I didn't realize is here.
Sort of like my check-in.
And even before I start with a settling or a breath or a mantra or something that settles the system,
I like to just do kind of snapshot and inevitably as I sit.
What's in my,
Something comes forward,
Always something.
Could be,
You know,
So many things.
There's a subtle mood,
You know,
A sense of energetic excitement.
Like if I'm doing it right now,
I can feel,
Ooh,
I love talking about this stuff.
There's excitement in my chest.
You know,
Sometimes there's like a sadness or a,
You know,
Or a fixation,
A quality I want to prove myself or I've got to get somewhere.
I have an expectation.
A subtle dysregulation,
Whatever it is,
I just,
Always something,
I just notice it,
I let it be there,
I kind of like,
Now,
Unlike focusing,
I don't do a,
I almost always experience a felt sense right away,
Because it's so fast now,
But I kind of feel into what's there,
I notice it,
I notice it's usually an energetic quality of the body,
But it could be memory,
An intuition,
A feeling,
All the different,
You know,
Felt sense things.
Usually.
Go into it too much.
Sometimes I do,
Though.
If there's a big thing there,
Then I'll do literally felt sense with myself.
I'll go,
Oh,
Interesting.
So what's this all about?
So if there's a big thing there,
That would be a criteria for spending more time in a felt sense way.
So that's important for people to know,
Right?
Oh,
That's where I can really start.
If you're a meditator,
Really start to notice if there's a big thing there,
That might be a valuable place to spend some time.
Yeah.
Well,
So I would say again,
This is really important.
Like there's different,
You can think of meditation.
It's like you begin a practice.
It's like you're in this atrium and there are like four or five doors leading in different directions and each is a different kind of path.
So just to give two very simple doors,
One,
It's completely legit.
I,
My teacher taught me like almost the first rule of practice is like focus towards or focus away.
Like where do you want to put your attention?
And it's a legitimate strategy to focus away.
So a lot of I think have stuff there but they go,
You know what I've learned how to create stability in my experience I'm gonna focus on this sense of a resource of calmness and I'm gonna let this other stuff be there and slowly fade away and they get ever more stable and grounded and that is a deep real valuable practice it that Stability radiates out they go back into their day.
They're able to find that composure more however They never really activate actively dealt with this thing.
It could be that indirectly the that you're cultivating through the settling will address that.
But I tend to,
My attitude is more like,
Hey,
If this is top of.
This is sitting at the top layer of the nervous system,
Why wouldn't I look at it and work to.
.
.
You know,
I think,
Just to interrupt there for a sec,
I think there's something there too that's really important about addiction.
So there's a ways that sometimes in recovery,
People will spend a lot of time on that first path of,
We could say it's like clearing space and focusing the meditate,
The mindfulness piece of it,
Where we're getting the right amount of distance to be able to stabilize or find more ventral energy in the body,
We would say in the,
In polyvagal theory.
The problem with that,
I think you're saying,
And I think this relates to addiction.
Process is that if you don't also go into that place and learn how to be comfortable enough to be with it in there,
That's where we can relapse.
Yes.
I couldn't agree more.
And then people go into those cycles and then they're like,
Why am I doing this again?
Yeah.
You know,
And there's an there's a absolutely one on one perfect and an analog in meditation.
And it has to do with these concentration and bliss states that you can get very good at developing.
In a sense,
You're you're you're like endogenously releasing your own opioids.
They're called the jhanas.
You can get into these deep,
Blissful states.
And the traditional criticism about those states from within Buddhism is that,
Yeah,
They're great for stability,
But it's not unlike,
Say,
Taking a drug that gives you a temporary thing.
They're not going to address the core issues and that you need an actual more insight practice to both to address those,
These trauma layers we're talking about,
And also to work on ultimately these deeper,
The kind of whole constructed nature of experience that deep practice is pointing itself to.
So,
So I agree with you,
You,
You end up avoiding those things and you end up in a,
In a,
In a very similar kind of,
You could say a kind of addiction cycle and yeah,
That's so interesting.
So Jeff,
Would you say that in the meditation world,
Is this idea that we're talking about now,
Is this radical?
Or is it kind of understood and accepted and part of.
.
.
Well,
I think honestly,
Because of the work of people like Peter Levine and Judith Herman and Basil and yourself and Stephen Porges,
I think that now,
Anytime you're doing a kind of training and learning mindfulness meditation,
There's going to be a section on what we can learn from trauma therapy.
I mean,
Embodied somatic trauma practice has become so hugely influential that almost everyone is fluent in a kind of window of tolerance model,
Nervous system activation model.
Okay,
Good.
That's wonderful.
But definitely when it comes to the mindfulness part that I think there's much more now in hardcore Buddhist circles where that aren't like so much about teaching mindfulness or learning insight practice that are more,
You know,
I think you can,
There's still lots of dissociators and there's still lots of people who are not necessarily directly addressing those things.
But I I do think it's changing.
There's so much more literacy.
Yeah,
It's wonderful,
Eh?
Yeah,
Yeah,
It is.
And anyway,
To,
Oh,
There's so much here.
But to go back to like,
So you go in,
I would go in and say,
Oh,
There is something here.
Now,
What's my process for that?
Because I've done a lot of work with focusing with you.
I've done a lot of meditation on my own.
I can,
Like I have specific ways I've learned of working that can very dramatically create shifts,
Like so much so that I'm often yawning and burping.
Yeah,
I can go like I have I'll go right to the heart of where often I identify,
Oh,
There's some strand of reactivity or way in which I'm trying to make this experience different.
And it's got an emotional charge.
It's got all this.
And I just trace it.
I trace it to the very beginning of it.
What is the initial trigger of this in a way in my experience?
Can I find the like where I believe or the core where I believe it's real?
And it's usually like I'm identifying with it in some way.
I think this is real.
I think this is who I am in some way.
And that's where my Buddhist practice is helpful i'm like oh but i don't i don't exist in that way that i think i do this is just the activity of the mind and body the activity of me but the place i'm aware from is is empty of all that and so this is kind of like a hybrid focusing and meditation practice and and then as soon as i do that there's this almost always a dramatic shift where the pattern like begins to that's where i'm yawning tears and just like all let's go that's there's the felt shift and in what we would say that then you're accessing more of of that ventral vagus.
Big time.
Yeah.
And that felt shift that Jenlin talked about that in my model brings together the nervous system.
Yes.
So then from that place,
Wow,
Now I'm in this place that I can really go into meditation.
So I've cleared the space similar to like a breath practice might clear the space different,
But a similar kind of thing.
I feel this groundedness,
The spaciousness.
And then I usually do a,
I might do a simple mantra or a breath or just a,
Just,
Just be.
And I feel the stability.
Ability of that just continuing to deepen and broaden.
And I begin to notice all these very,
Very,
Very subtle activations that are there in experience that I don't normally think of.
I think of this as like the sound of the fridge,
Becoming aware of the sound of the fridge.
You've been in the kitchen for the past two hours.
You didn't even notice the sound of the fridge was on,
But it's been humming in the background.
Now it starts to go off.
And that is a place of rich,
Rich inquiry.
I don't know how much felt sense spends time there.
You know,
It's like spent felt since it's such an active and dynamic process.
This is an exploration of deep stillness and quiet and showing that there's so many several layers in our self thing and our identification process that are available for inquiry and inspection should we wish.
And from that place,
I often end up going into either like a non dual inquiry or like a mindless one or I just do nothing.
Surrender to it and I let the space work on me because I know that's the teacher here.
Yeah,
I love that.
And that,
That would be more in Jenlin's experiencing scale down at level six and seven where we're,
And you're right,
There is a way in step six,
We call welcoming and people,
A lot of people in the community will say,
We really need to like expand this because this is where so much of the goodies stuff is.
And it just goes deeper and deeper.
I mean,
That's the mystery you get into that.
It's hard to even articulate.
It's,
It's,
It's the essence of spirituality.
And the contemplative insight of like,
Oh my gosh,
The unity,
The interconnection,
The quiet,
The love,
It's like,
It's all in there.
And it's not just some bland pablum thing.
It could be very finely elaborated.
There's details,
Your own stuff is- And for those of us in the audience who know my four circle practice,
And probably Robert is there,
But this is the fourth circle,
Right?
This is that really deep,
Just such a gorgeous place.
Gorgeous.
Yeah.
And it's,
You know,
It's the place of interconnectivity.
Yeah.
It's like,
It's the place of deep service,
You know,
Those impulses,
The naturalness of those impulses.
Yeah.
Sometimes I call it like being in contact with the stream.
Yeah.
Like what is the deep stream of intuitions about how to be in our life and what we're going to do.