This podcast episode is for my people with hearty appetites because I think this subject is less talked about in binge eating recovery.
And I think it's a bigger piece of the puzzle than most people realize.
I also don't believe that everybody has the same kind of appetite.
I think some of us have heartier appetites than others.
I am somebody who has always had a hearty appetite,
Even since I was a kid.
I always ate more than what I needed.
My peers probably,
And even to this day,
This is true.
And so while everything I say today will not be applicable to everybody or within everybody's same experience,
I think that for those of us who have hearty appetites,
The concepts here are going to be relevant because appetite is so minimized.
In what's allowed really in diet culture,
It's not okay,
It's uncouth almost.
And it's certainly not feminine to have a big appetite and also I think that sometimes,
A lot of times,
And this is kind of the premise of today's episode,
Is that appetite gets misrepresented as mental hunger.
So let me start with appetite before I get to mental hunger and how I see that because mental hunger is something I'm going to divide up into categories because it's not just one thing.
But first,
Let me introduce the subject of appetite to help us understand how mental hunger and appetite are connected.
So I want to start actually with an example that just happened in my WhatsApp when a client was talking me through her day of eating.
And she is someone who struggles with feeling like she can trust herself with food.
She doesn't validate the places where she does have really good intuition with her with her eating,
Which I think she does see her making choices and like picking up on signals and cues and her body that are.
Spot on and really shows a lot of presence with herself.
But she has this feeling that she eats too much and that she's not intuitive because she eats too much.
So she was talking me through yesterday some of the food choices that she'd made.
And she was like,
Well,
An example of why I think I can't trust myself is because I had dinner And I'd had lunch and I'd had my breakfast and I'd had my snacks.
I'd had all my food.
It wasn't like,
You know,
We're not restricting here.
And I got to dinner and I had,
And what she described was a piece of meat,
Like a protein,
A scoop of rice,
Some spinach,
And then bread and olive oil as well.
And when I read it and when I heard it,
I was thinking,
Wow,
Like,
You know,
That,
That's such almost like a,
That plate of food there,
Like the protein on the plate,
The scoop of rice and the vegetable is something you would have seen in the diet plans in the back of the magazines.
I know I'm dating myself there,
But I think they still exist in some form.
Or it's like what you take an Instagram picture of,
Or it's a Weight Watchers meal.
And there's nothing wrong with it inherently.
It's vegetable,
It's carbohydrate,
It's protein.
The olive oil in there offers the fat.
It's the components that make up a meal that we need from the macronutrient point of view.
It's portions of each.
And yet,
And I'm going to say this admitting my own bias and my subjectivity,
When I picture a plate like that,
There's something about it that feels to me like there's scarcity in it.
There's a part of me that's like,
If I ate a piece of chicken breast.
A scoop of spinach and a scoop of rice,
I would be hungry afterwards.
Like,
Even though on the surface,
Cognitively,
You'd look at that and say,
Yeah,
That's a meal,
That's a standard meal.
And perhaps,
And I believe that for some people it is,
And some people could have that meal,
Especially if you're including a piece of bread too,
And be done and be finished afterwards.
And there's times where I could be done after that.
It is possible that that's a meal that would satiate me sometimes.
But not every time.
I think we all walk around kind of believing that the pictures of what enough is that we've inherited from magazines,
From diet plans,
From things like Weight Watchers or any of those things,
Noom,
The diet culture imagery at large,
The standard dinner.
Implicitly has braided within it some kind of scarcity.
I think that the imagery of dinner we have is generally,
Where did we get that imagery?
Usually when we're looking at diet plans and stuff like that.
So there's some kind of assumption that that's standard fare,
And sometimes it is.
But if you have an appetite that goes beyond that sometimes,
It's not enough.
And also appetite varies in range,
Right?
So some days you can eat one thing and it satisfies you and fills you and then another day you might find that you eat that very same thing and you're hungry again,
And you're hungry again,
And you're hungry again,
Because appetite shifts,
It fluctuates.
Again,
That's also individual.
There are some people for whom they have relatively stable appetites every day.
But that is,
I think,
I think we've taken a subset of normal and normalized it for everybody.
And I don't think that it is.
I have repeatedly run up against this in my life.
And in my recovery,
It has proven it out where my body,
And I'm sure I'm not alone.
Isn't the kind of body that can make do with standard portions 100% of the time.
If I'm operating under the assumption that a scoop of rice,
Spinach,
And a meat and a piece of bread even with it is going to fill me,
I will sometimes be right,
But I will sometimes be wrong.
And all the times that I'm wrong.
I will think it's a me problem,
And I don't think that it is.
I think that we actually have bigger appetites than the pictures make it look like we should have.
And again,
I'm a midsize woman,
So I live in a size 12-ish body,
And I need more food than I need.
My thinner counterparts.
And I used to have this,
Like what I would think at this point in the process would be,
Well,
Steph,
It is a problem with you because if you ate the standard fare,
If you ate less,
You would be thinner.
And here you are complaining that you're,
You know,
You're,
You're not a size X,
You're a size X.
You know,
I always had a problem with being as quote unquote big as I was,
Even though it's still in a straight size body,
Being mid-sized to me was always still an,
You were still had to be aspirational towards thinness.
Size 12,
Like you better get it down.
Like you're the kind of person who needs to be kind of a little bit apologizing for being mid-size and working your way up.
Way down.
And so.
The obvious truth to me throughout my life was that,
Yeah,
I have this bigger appetite and that's why you're not thin.
And I guess if I follow that,
Which I did at some point,
You know,
It's kind of like,
Okay,
Well,
If I take my appetite down to quote unquote normal,
If I take it down to what a standard plate of dinner would create and the kind of body that I would get if I ate that on a regular basis,
Which is what I did in restriction and beyond.
I mean,
I obviously restricted further than that too.
But even if I,
If I ate now,
What is recommended.
Even the RDA in the US at 2000 calories per day,
If I do that.
No one's going to say to me,
You're restricting,
Right?
Because it's still more than like even restrictive mindsets.
That's standard.
And I will lose weight doing that.
And I will get down to a thinner size.
And I will also lose my period.
And I will be obsessed with food.
And I will be tired.
And I will be extremely irritable.
And I will live for nothing else than food.
I will eventually start binging.
And I will dream about,
I mean,
I've done that,
Right?
So while you could say that needing more than the standard appetite would suggest you should have,
Is potentially somebody could be like,
Well,
That's too much.
And that's why you wait.
That's why you're not thin.
That's why you're not as thin as you could be.
And I've been taught that I should be eating less to make up for that.
And if I do,
I will have disordered eating.
And so I believe that some of us are just bred to be bigger and we will have bigger appetites than what is standardly discussed as appropriate.
In culture.
That does not mean that I'm wrong or that my body's wrong or that my appetite's wrong.
It means that I am meant to eat more than a person who might need less than me because my body is built to be bigger and will not tolerate being smaller without a fight.
And that was essentially what my life story ended up being,
Was that I tried to push my appetite down to the place it needed to be to be thin.
And I only ended up with an eating disorder.
I mean,
Granted,
I also pushed it lower.
But even after that,
After my period of time in high school,
When I went really,
Really restrictive,
I mean,
Certainly had other very highly restrictive periods,
Bouncing back and forth between restriction and binge eating for many,
Many years.
But there were there were periods in my 20s and 30s where I was simply trying to eat a quote unquote normal amount.
I was trying to eat that description of the plate that I just gave you.
And I couldn't do that.
I couldn't do that.
I couldn't have the magazine prescription of a breakfast,
Lunch,
Dinner,
And snacks because my appetite demands more.
And as soon as I try to push my appetite down into the range that normal suggests it should be,
I develop disordered patterns,
Including binge eating.
We are taught that that's our problem,
Right?
Because how could it not be when you're not even restricting here?
And my argument is that some of us need to have more than what you think is an appropriate amount.
Now here's a way that I see that manifesting in recovery.
So one of the things that I think about a lot now is how when I get really hungry or when I find myself eating more food than I used to think I should at a meal,
The reason that I know for sure that it is intuitive eating and not overeating is because I get full at some point.
It takes more food for me to get full and satiated than I thought it should.
But I don't keep going and keep going and keep going and keep going,
Which would indicate something else going on.
But I will just need a certain amount of food to kind of like,
It's almost like I picture a lever in the stomach that once it gets hit,
Once it gets pressed enough,
It's like,
Good to go.
We're good.
We can go now.
We can think about other things.
We feel satiated.
Goodbye.
And I will reach that point.
I feel this physical cue in my body that's like,
Ah,
There it is.
There it is.
I'm done now.
I know I'm done now.
What I think happens to many people who have hearty appetites is that they believe that the amount of food that it takes to hit that place is too much.
And so before the point of satiation,
They are already starting to judge themselves and think,
Here I go again.
And this is going to introduce the concept of meta eating,
Which is eating because you feel guilty that you've eaten or eating because you feel guilty that you're eating too much.
And so you keep,
You eat now more than you even would have needed because of that fear or that judgment,
Or even the belief that you are now binging.
And this happened to me a lot in the beginning of recovery,
Where I would just like marvel at this.
And one of the places that this will show up for me a lot is like breakfast time.
There are some mornings that I wake up and I have breakfast as usual and like whatever,
The day just moves.
But sometimes I wake up and this will typically happen on a weekend.
I think there's also a psychological component to this.
My body really likes to front load,
Especially on the weekends.
It's hungrier in the morning.
It appreciates eating more food in the morning.
And so I will have breakfast in the morning.
And then sometimes I need a second breakfast.
And sometimes I need an early lunch too.
Like sometimes I need a significant amount of food before noon.
And I know that before when I would get those very same cues,
Which I now understand as intuitive and which serve me really well throughout my day to day.
I would think you're starting the binge now.
And here we go.
And now I've got a psychological setup for having failed.
And now I'm going to start to eat because I'm like,
What the hell eating.
But actually my body wasn't ever really wrong in the first place.
I wasn't starting to binge.
I was simply doing what my body does instinctively now,
Which is collecting more food in the morning.
That doesn't look like.
If you're following a meal plan,
That doesn't look like it's copacetic.
It looks like you're too greedy.
Like you're supposed to be full after X,
Y,
And Z amount of calories or amount of density,
Right?
But if your body isn't,
And it needs that times one and a half,
Or that times two,
Or that times three.
And your body actually does need it.
But you're judging that you need it because you're basing your standards off of something else,
You have now just decided or labeled that binge eating behavior or overeating behavior or emotional eating.
So that was really what I thought.
I thought that that was the beginning of my emotional eating.
Which was essentially the same thing to me as a binge or it would turn into a binge.
So what was the difference anyway?
I think this was such.
A travesty that I inherited that understanding in that way because it was never emotional eating.
It was,
Well,
I shouldn't say it was never emotional eating.
Emotional eating did absolutely play a role in my life in a way that did turn into binges in a separate way.
But when I'm talking about this experience of having a stronger appetite that I was simply meeting that didn't look the way that it's prescribed to us or that people normalize in society,
I assumed that was emotional eating and therefore I would then start binging.
And that meta eating,
That eating because you now feel guilty about it,
Is a phenomenon that many,
Many people are experiencing and clumping together as one eating behavior.
It's really two.
It's really appetite demanding food.
And then judgment of that,
And then eating in response to that judgment.
There is a threshold point where you cross over from eating to appetite to eating in response to guilt.
That is a powerful place that meta eating because it can start to take on a life of its own.
Because once you get into what the hell eating,
You are no longer really responding to appetite,
You're no longer really registering the cues of satiation,
Because now you're guilty and you're you're blowing right by them.
Because there's something that happens there when you're in a place of feeling like,
What the hell,
I think that whatever's happening in the psychology at that point is changing the way that fullness and satiation feel.
It's almost like it dulls it a bit.
And instead of feeling the satiation cue and like,
Ah,
Registering that and being able to say,
I'm OK to lean away from food now,
The psychological heaviness of the guilt and of the expectation of now I'm going to do this,
Now I'm going to feel like this,
This is what's coming for me,
Almost the helplessness and powerlessness of that,
I think inherently changes the satiation cue itself and begins to breed a kind of like like a storing mechanism.
Like now I need to just gather gravity in my stomach because almost maybe to escape if that's the,
If that's the modus operandi,
Like we need to escape this guilt feeling,
Therefore we need more density.
We need to be satisfied with more because escapism requires that we're heavier.
There's more of a sensory need in the input in the stomach to combat the feelings of guilt,
Which,
Which does cross over into emotional eating.
Like that could be talked about through the lens of emotional eating.
But my argument is that for many of us,
Begin there.
It wasn't an emotional eating experience to begin with.
It was actually an appetite experience.
And when you recover,
And when I say that,
When I say when you recover,
I mean,
When you work on not pathologizing your food.
And in my case,
You know,
I did an all-in process.
And so the part of me that would feel guilty,
I eliminated.
And of course,
I mean,
That's a lot easier said than done.
But when I went into my all-in process,
What I was basically saying was you can eat as much as you need to eat without questioning it.
And that's going to be allowed for a period of time.
Which,
You know,
The years of work I had done prior to embarking on this experience had allowed that.
I was really on board with that.
I understood it from almost a scientific point of view when I started this.
When I started all in.
And so because I kind of got rid,
I was like,
All right,
Well,
Now guilt isn't a factor.
Now I'm not going to be sitting here trying to eat less.
So I took that element out.
At which point I started to notice like,
Oh,
I'm full.
It took me longer than I thought it should to get here.
And because I don't have the guilt now.
.
.
I can feel it.
I can feel that.
And I'm not judging that.
I'm not judging how much it took to get here.
And now I am actually free to keep moving and to stop eating.
Because I'm not now stuck in the guilt response,
Which has another impact that I wasn't going into the emotional eating component because I didn't have to.
I wasn't trying to escape an emotion because that emotion didn't exist anymore because guilt was not part of the protocol of what I was doing.
So I want to let this lead into what mental hunger is,
Because mental hunger,
And just for definition sake,
Is the psychological,
It's like psychological hunger,
Meaning it's thoughts about food.
And really what it,
What the new term of the day is for it is food noise.
Okay.
So it's,
It's that feeling like you can't stop thinking about food and your brain,
It's almost like your brain wants food.
Now,
The way that this is presented,
I think,
And to,
Discussed at large is that this is a fake hunger.
So we only want to validate physiological hunger.
We think hunger is only real if your organs and like your body need the energy to function.
It's that very,
Very mechanical definition of what hunger is.
And it should only come from your stomach,
Right?
Like your stomach growling,
That's hunger.
That's hunger that maybe we could get behind,
That we're like,
Yeah,
Okay.
If we're lucky.
If we will give ourselves that much.
This is also why people will be like,
I don't feel guilty eating when I'm hungry.
That's why I like getting hungry,
Because it makes me feel like I deserve the food.
I mean,
This is another common one,
Right?
Feeling hungry,
We don't feel like we should be eating.
And there's different ways we could talk about that another day.
But mental hunger is one of the kinds that we don't validate.
We think mental hunger is just this like nuisance.
And I think that is what a lot of people who use weight loss medications are trying,
They're trying to get around,
Right?
They're kind of like,
All I do all day is think about food.
And that's an invasion of me.
Like that's,
That's like a wrong signal.
And this medication basically says shush to appetite and then now you're not thinking about food anymore.
Because I think that mental hunger is very much related to appetite.
And this is not going to be any surprise to any of you who have been following me for a long time.
And I will also talk about mental hunger as it's not related to appetite.
But I think most,
Do I say most?
I don't know if I can say that.
Yeah,
But I could.
Like I think,
I think a lot of what people are calling food noise as a pathology and medicating it is hunger.
It is appetite that we haven't validated.
I will say I don't think that's the case for everyone and I do think there are metabolic conditions where a person may be getting cues to eat.
That are coming from a deficiency in the system or like a,
For lack of a better word,
Like a glitch in the system.
We know,
For example,
That insulin sensitivity can create a need to keep eating sugars and carbohydrates because of the way that food is processed through the cells.
It is a real and true hunger call from the body,
It's not made up,
But it's not receiving the kind of satisfaction that we would expect the cells to be processing in a body that didn't have insulin sensitivity,
That wasn't sensitive,
You know,
Like that was actually like,
Yeah,
Good,
We're stable,
We can keep moving and we're not going to keep needing.
But I think that in the absence of having that kind of a situation going on.
I also know that with GLP-1s,
What GLP-1s address is that like some bodies,
Some cells do not have,
We all have GLP-1 in our bodies.
We all make that naturally.
And that some people don't release as much GLP-1 after eating than others.
So that can also be true.
I'm not arguing that that is something that can be true and that that would also cause mental hunger.
It would cause physical hunger,
Which is causing mental hunger.
What I'm saying is that I think there are a great amount of people who believe that they have have a deficiency or that they need GLP-1s because their body's glitching.
When in fact what's actually happening is that they have not validated how hearty their appetite actually is because they're using the models of what is normal to contrast themselves against and thinking that's a them problem.
And I can tell you that this is 100% what I would have,
Like,
If GLP once had come on,
On scene,
When I was in my 20s or 30s,
100%,
I would have been like,
That's me.
I don't make enough GLP.
Like,
That's why I binge because clearly I'm eating enough.
And there's so many different things wrong with that,
Like in terms of what I thought enough was and also the way in which I was eating enough.
But with the hearty appetite designed for my mid-sized body,
2,
000 calories a day wasn't enough for me.
And it wasn't,
And it still isn't.
And then nothing to do with my GLP-1.
You know,
It had nothing to do with my metabolic inefficiencies and it certainly had nothing to do with my gluttony.
It's simply because I have a heartier appetite than we're taught to believe we should have.
So I think that mental hunger needs to be considered first,
Especially if you are somebody who has a history of restriction and that is in the past or active now,
Or even if you don't,
But maybe if you just relate to having a heartier appetite,
That if you're able to reach satiation,
And it's not the case that you eat and you eat and you eat and you never can find satiation,
Like there could be something at play here that's more related to appetite than to a problem,
Then that mental hunger is a representation of a problem.
We know that mental hunger is the way that the brain gives attention,
Brings our attention back to food so that we go get it.
That's the function of it.
It is not an accident.
It's not like a made up pipe dream in your brain.
It's your brain saying,
I need us to start thinking about food and I need us to kind of ruminate there because I need to go get it.
We need it.
We're hungry.
It is a way that hunger shows up in the system.
Mental hunger can absolutely be real hunger,
Just manifesting through a different strategy.
Instead of growling through your stomach to get your attention,
It's getting your attention through the psychology,
Especially if we're people who kind of push down the physical symptoms.
The other piece of this I want to name is that even if,
And this is what I would have thought too,
Let's say that I eat enough food in a sitting that I am satiated.
I am.
I won't say satiated.
I will say I will.
I'm full but not finished.
Right.
Like I feel acutely full.
But I feel like I could keep eating.
I feel like I need more,
I need more.
I'm like bottomless almost,
That feeling of bottomlessness.
Sometimes when you have what I call a cumulative hunger or collective hunger,
That means that you can be acutely full in the moment,
Your stomach can be full with food,
But if you have,
If you're under your weight set point,
Or if you have any,
If you haven't been eating to your appetite for a period of time,
Because your body will let you get away with it for a little while,
That you have like built up hunger,
Your ghrelin will have built up and built up.
So you could,
Ghrelin is the hunger hormone.
So if you have ghrelin built up in your your body.
You're going to feel hungry even if you have food in your stomach,
Because it's not about what you need right now in this hour.
It's about what you needed from this morning,
From yesterday,
From last week,
From last month,
From last year,
Right?
Like the body catching up to the stored hunger is what often presents to people as this bottomless hunger that is then pathologized because they're like,
Well,
I'm not hungry.
I just ate.
I can feel fullness in my stomach.
And yet there's some part of me that wants to keep going.
Is very distinct.
It's not the same as what compulsive eating feels like.
It's not necessarily a bottomlessness that compulsive eating is responding to.
It's more like I just can't stop.
I'm sort of caught in a loop.
Bottomless hunger,
You can feel full in your stomach,
But it's almost like there's something,
The way I think about it and feel it,
Is like there's like an emptiness or a hollow part of the stomach,
A compartment that's behind it or under it.
It just can keep taking more,
Even though I can still feel the fullness in the front of my stomach.
That's the kind of the way that I picture it.
Or feel it.
It's a sense almost in a way that you could eat a lot of food and then you can.
And eventually you get to a point of satiation.
And at that point,
It might look like a lot of overeating or even a binge.
And I think in the beginning of my all-in process,
I was eating enough food that it would have constituted a binge from the viewpoint of calories.
But it was really my cumulative hunger asking for what it needed because I had spent so many years in this back-and-forth binge-restrict cycle that my body was in fact suppressed for me,
Even though nobody else would have called me weight-suppressed.
In fact,
They would have said,
I look great.
Right where I should be,
But it wasn't where I should be.
And I know that now because I don't binge anymore at all.
I am extremely intuitive with my food and my body size is higher than what it quote-unquote should be.
Another way that we might experience mental hunger,
Even where we feel fullness,
Is through that bottomlessness that is actually representation of stored hunger and needing more food to kind of catch up with where we have been,
Even inadvertently restricting due to our ideas of what appetite should look like.
But let's even move from that.
So not everybody is having that experience.
And I know that the permitters out there would say that that isn't necessarily what they're feeling and maybe what they're feeling is more mental hunger is representing like if they start thinking about food,
That they can't let it go,
Even though they haven't been hungry a day in their lives for years,
You know,
Like it's not a case of restriction.
However,
I am a huge believer in the role of psychological restriction as equally valid to our binge response as physiological restriction,
Meaning that if we are judging ourselves constantly for what we're eating or how we're eating,
I will give you an example of this one.
I have a client who has been binging daily.
This is a new client and she has been binging daily for a long period of time.
And we started working together very recently and extremely quickly,
I recognized because in our WhatsApp conversations,
All I was hearing was that every day she was waking up like,
Today's the day,
Today's the day that I'm going to stop this nonsense,
Right?
And even though we'd had discussions about this isn't going to be a quick fix,
And we can't expect ourselves to just stop binging just because we started a program and things like that.
The expectation every day,
The belief would come back up and it would just kind of,
It didn't matter what the conversation was prior.
It was like,
Today's the day that I'm going to get it together.
And what getting it together meant,
You know,
Is,
Is individual to everybody,
Right?
What does that mean to us?
So for some of us,
It's like,
I'm going to finally take control of my health.
I have fatty liver and high cholesterol.
This isn't a restriction thing.
This isn't about vanity.
I need to get it together for my health.
It kind of doesn't matter what the reason is.
If we have this expectation that we're going to whip ourselves into shape all of a sudden,
And that,
You know,
The ideals we have,
Whether they're weight-based or health-based are going to arrive because they need to,
And they should.
They would.
We are setting ourselves up for unrealistic expectations and those unrealistic expectations translate into pressure and in some cases,
Shame.
That pressure and shame of these unrealistic expectations,
Even,
By the way,
If those expectations make sense to you in the long run,
If you're expecting that we're just going to get there,
Right?
If you put the cart before the horse.
They're unrealistic.
And you can keep them as goals if you want.
Like I have a client who has some goals about nutrition that it's fair.
You know,
Yes,
Yes,
These goals can be had,
But you can't expect that you're going to just like arrive there tomorrow because you think you should,
Right?
So if what,
What I believe happens here is that the nervous system is perceiving these unrealistic expectations.
And it's like,
Oh hell no,
I can't be expected to just like do all of that work,
Like to change overnight.
And I also feel like potentially these expectations are a little bit too much,
Too fast.
I feel pressured and I need to first,
Before we do anything,
Establish my own agency.
And agency.
For better or for worse.
Is something that your psychology will fight for,
Even if it means sabotaging,
And I use that word carefully,
I don't really think it's sabotage,
I think it's misaligned parts,
But it will,
What looks like,
Sabotage other parts of you that are otherwise health-pursuing parts.
So for example,
What I mean by this is,
This client that I'm talking about has some health-related goals that I respect,
You know,
And I think that we can have health-related goals.
And let's even say that somebody has a weight-related goal.
Now,
That's not something I generally talk about,
But I'm including it here for purposes of inviting in all parts of this conversation to still kind of get to the point that we're trying to see here.
Even if you have a weight-related goal or a health-related goal that you believe,
And you really feel at heart,
That it's not a restriction,
It's not meant to be a self-punishment,
You're not having unrealistic expectations of yourself,
You just want to have fun.
Some general health or maybe you're like,
You know what,
I just want to lose some weight because I'm in a position where my mobility is affected by my weight.
I don't think there's anything wrong with talking about that.
Like I don't think we need to cancel that conversation in terms of hearing somebody out in terms of what they want,
Right?
Okay.
It's not a behavior.
It's just a,
It's just a thought at this point.
Your psychology potentially will put those goals second in line.
To put autonomy and agency first.
So it won't get on board with your health goals if it doesn't feel like you are making choices that come from realistic expectations of yourself.
And I actually think that that part of us is great.
I think,
Look,
I also understand how it can actually be and I've had,
I've seen this too with clients where like it's taking the whole ship under.
I think in some cases this part of us is great and like in my case,
That part of me,
I learned to respect and that part of me is my fiercest ally now.
I don't have,
Like I have great respect for the part of me that that's demanding my agency first.
It's what keeps me in critical thinking.
It's what keeps me out of comparison.
It's the part of me that's like,
You will do you,
Steph,
You know,
And I need this part.
But for other,
I've seen this also take somebody down where it's like in the pursuit of this agency and autonomy,
We basically end up binging every day and that that's really what that binging is representing is the fight for agency.
I don't make the rules.
I just play by them.
So I respect and I understand that human psychology values agency.
I get it.
And I think understanding that that's sometimes what's at play here with mental hunger is that if your psychology is saying,
I perceive that we're acting under a pressure system rather than A self-led system?
And or that we're trying to do too much too fast and that's going to overwhelm us and make us feel helpless.
I'm going to actually assert the call to food through mental hunger as a way of interrupting the cycle of compliance.
And I think in some ways that is how mental hunger is showing up.
All of which points back to how do we start to number one,
Go slower,
Start being more patient and realistic about our goals,
Which is oftentimes the issue.
We really get into urgency and I get it.
I know why we get into urgency because sometimes we're suffering a lot.
I mean,
Obviously like it is,
It is suffering in so many ways to be binging and to have this relationship with food.
In our body image as well.
The stigma out there,
Weight stigma,
There is suffering that's going on and the urgency to kind of like fix it,
Get out of it,
Get away from it is high.
And the psychology will still be like,
I just don't care.
You know,
Like I just need us to go slower.
I need us to have a more realistic approach.
I need us to be more gray area.
I need us to not demand such high performance right away.
We need to take it down a notch,
You know,
In terms of the expectations we have of ourselves.
And I think this is why there's a big intersection of perfectionism with binge eating.
And there is,
There's a huge intersection there.
And remembering that perfectionism is not doing things perfectly.
It is the idea that you can or should be doing things perfectly.
That is another place that I think that mental hunger shows up where it is not necessarily related to appetite,
But it is related to agency.
And agency may also be related to appetite,
In which case this all comes full circle where we say something like,
I need to understand that what my appetite is and what's good for me and how much I need to eat is not going to be dependent upon what anyone else eats or what the prescriptions are about how much I should eat.
That is also agency.
And this is where understanding what your actual natural born appetite is,
Actually understanding what your natural born like body,
Your God given body,
Whether we like it or not,
Right,
Like that,
Where our body wants to naturally sit.
I know that that's also a really tricky subject.
But you know,
Generally accepting our general range is,
Is agency,
It's,
It seems like it's surrender.
And everybody wants to call it like letting yourself go or giving up or whatever.
But it's actually agency,
Because what good is fighting it doing,
It's actually undermining everything.
So being able to say,
I know who I am and I can accept who I am and what I look like and what my body is and what my appetite is,
Despite the fact that the rest of the world tells me it's wrong.
That is,
I think that's the ultimate agency.
And potentially what your mental hunger is advocating for as well.
There is a third kind of category,
I think,
Of mental hunger that is not related to appetite or agency.
And it is where the overwhelm in the nervous system leads into or meshes with emotional eating.
And this is where we fall into a place of food as escape.
Food as compulsion in a way that doesn't have anything,
That isn't about like the physiology and the psychology of appetite.
More about the nervous system needing food as a hideaway or as a coping mechanism for overwhelming the nervous system.
So I will use myself as an example here.
At a certain period during a certain period of my life,
I would wake up every day and just like start binging.
Pretty quickly,
You know what I mean?
Like it was such a part of my day and,
Or I would kind of wake up and again,
I would still just try to have like a quote unquote normal breakfast,
Normal lunch,
Normal dinner,
And then be binging at night.
I still can't fully separate that from my expectations of myself.
And I think that anybody who's talking about eating compulsively in a way that doesn't readily lend itself to feeling like it's restrictive based,
Still has to consider that there may also be some expectation of what normal looks like that doesn't match up with a realistic expectation.
But let's say that it doesn't.
And I would say there was probably a period of time where I was eating as much as my body would have needed and still binging at night.
And that it wasn't really primarily coming from a restrictive place,
At least at that point,
It wasn't.
It may have started,
Like I have had restriction in my history,
But the active ingredients during this time making me binge was more compulsive,
Emotional,
Habitual patterns of my nervous system in a groove it couldn't get out of.
A lot of times people will ask me about this like,
Is there such a thing as habit-based binging?
But I do believe there can be a habitual element to binging that becomes compulsive eating where emotional safety is involved and emotional safety was needed and maybe is no longer needed,
But the groove of the nervous system is such that it kind of hasn't caught up,
Right?
The nervous system hasn't realized we don't need that anymore,
But the fusing together of safety in escaping emotion or overriding emotion with food.
Has now gotten itself kind of entangled in what safety is.
So there's this glitch now happening.
Those cases are much more rare in my experience working with people.
And that could also have to do with the cohort of people that come to me,
Right?
The people who resonate with my content,
The things I talk about.
I think,
I don't know,
Maybe 10%,
Maybe 15%.
Of people who I have worked with are in a position where that's what they're dealing with.
Most often,
It's some combination of what I've talked about previously with appetite,
With psychology,
And or a combination of all three.
Rarely do I see somebody who is just strictly dealing with binge eating that is unrelated to appetite or psychology and agency,
And only in the habitual sort of nervous system glitch due to the emotional,
What amounts to essentially trauma.
I find that this cohort of people has a strong history of trauma,
Typically,
Where there's a really sensitive coding of food and safety together that have been the way that somebody's been able to cope with an overwhelming emotional experience that now the system's having a hard time getting,
Like letting go of.
In this.
Group of people.
This is one of the only places where some of the strategies around food like this is the group of people who won't do well typically with the going rate strategies out there for food issues,
Even with the new evolved ways of allowing all foods and food permission and things like that.
This cohort of people will generally not do well there because the permission piece and the allowing all foods piece is is working with appetite and agency,
Right?
It's helping those parts feel safe.
Whereas for somebody who's almost like food is my agency,
Like food is the way that I've actually Saved myself.
The permission around that isn't quite as liberating.
It's almost entrapping.
It's almost furthering the glitch.
It's keeping that more alive.
Now,
That doesn't mean that somebody in this group of people doesn't need permission.
We do.
We all need to feel agency.
We all need to feel permission.
But I think the way that it gets interpreted,
Typically,
Is that it's more like permission to binge rather than permission to make choices.
And it's also reinforces the safety association with food,
Which is something that they're trying to get away from.
So this is a group of people where agency can sometimes come from structure and it comes from it comes from more what can be more like some people might feel is more diet culture adjacent models like like not keeping all foods in the house or having more guidelines and boundaries around how food is structured through the day or how it looks because in a state of like nervous system overwhelm,
Containment is really important to establish safety first,
To then go back out into like expansion and like exploring and curiosity and choice.
So in some nervous systems,
In order to get to a place of flexibility and safety with agency,
Even there has to be a sense of containment first.
Agency can be a little too overwhelming.
There's too many decisions to make.
There's too much freedom,
Even in having a choice.
Something that in somatic experiencing is called global high activation.
So this is somebody who is just in chronic states of being activated,
Like never coming out of it really.
Containment is necessary first.
That sense of being held having boundaries,
Like understanding where boundaries are,
Needs to be baseline before we're getting out into into something different.
Now I know that like hearing that you might be like,
I don't know where I fall like I could see myself in any one of those,
You know,
And of course,
As this is a podcast,
And I don't know if you're listening where you specifically would fall.
But I would say that in the latter category that I mentioned,
I think some people would potentially think they're there,
But not necessarily,
That might not apply.
This is where binging has gotten to a point where it is so compulsive and pervasive that it's taken over one's life.
And that doesn't mean that everybody who's binging has taken over their life is in this category,
Because binging took over my life too,
But I wasn't in that category.
If restriction and agency are at play,
You can also have binging that's taken over your life.
I think there's a difference between compulsive eating and binging.
Versus extreme hunger,
Which by the way,
I think that when we're talking about that appetite stuff we were talking about in the beginning,
I don't even think that's binging the way we talk about binging.
I mean,
Technically it is,
But it's really,
It's appetite eating.
It's eating to appetite.
When it crosses over into meta eating,
Then we might be getting into binging territory.
But I think binging is a word that encompasses so many different things that happen for so many different reasons that it's really lacking nuance to really understand what's what.